Advantages,
Disadvantages and Print Quality:
I tested the printer against a
variety of laser and inkjet printers. I printed in
color, black & white, and grayscale, and I printed
full color pages, used the foil colors, and spot
color. The quality was as good as or even better
than what was produced on either the color laser or
the inkjet printers. Many people buy two or more
printers it is difficult to find just one printer
that prints crisp text and color graphics or
photographs. The MD-5000 gives you exceptional
results in both text and photographs at an
affordable price. Below is a discussion of different
printing technologies and their strengths and
weaknesses. In determining what printer to buy, I
feel it is not necessarily a decision on which is
better but what is more appropriate for a persons
needs, i.e., what is it going to be used for, and
what can you afford.
Color Printing
I think it's important to understand the
mechanism of color printing and why you get
dithering and jaggies on some printers and why
dye sublimation printers such as the Alps give
you continuous tone or photographic quality
prints. Color printing uses four separate
pigments: cyan, yellow, magenta, and black. This
system is called CYMK. (K stands for black.)
Some low-end color inkjet printers save the cost
of a black ink print head by using equal
portions of magenta, yellow, and cyan to produce
black. But the resulting black lacks density,
which is why better personal printers include a
print head for black ink. All color printers use
tiny dots of those four inks to create various
shades of color on the page. Lighter shades are
created by leaving dots of unprinted white. Some
printers, such as dye-sublimation, control the
size of the dots and produce continuous-tone
images that rival photography. But most printers
create dots that are essentially the same size
no matter how much of a particular color is
needed. For all shades beyond the eight that are
produced by overlaying the primaries, the
printer generates a varied pattern of
differently colored dots. For example, the
printer uses a combination of 1 magenta dot to
two of cyan to produce a deep purple. For most
shades of color, the dots of ink are not printed
on top of each other. Instead, they are offset
slightly, a process called dithering. The eye
accommodatingly blends the dots to form the
desired shade as it hides the jagged edges, or
jaggies, produced by the dots. Dithering can
produce nearly 17 million colors. The type of
paper used in color printing affects the quality
of the hard copy. Dithering is more apparent on
inkjets
Inkjet Printers
Inkjet printers spray ink through tiny jets,
or nozzles, onto the paper. All in all, inkjet
printers deliver great and affordable results,
but there are some downsides. The ink from an
inkjet printer tends to migrate, or spread out,
on the paper, making the print look less sharp
because the "dot" is less defined. This is where
you get jaggies or jagged text. A harder, less
absorbable paper, such as paper with a glossy
surface, helps contain ink migration, but the
ink might take a few minutes to dry. You should
handle a page, especially one with a lot of
dense color on it, with care. Inkjets can be
slow. It takes a lot of time for the print head
to scan across the page and deliver ink. There
are printers that are designed specifically for
printing photos which give good detail and very
accurate color. Although you can use plain paper
to get a quick draft image printed, a better
paper grade, such as a good-quality laser paper,
yields better results. Inkjet prints fade
quickly and smear easily unless they have a
protective coating. A good photographic inkjet
printer can give you outstanding quality images
on special paper. They are also good for general
office work where you want an inexpensive
printer that can handle volume. Many of the
older versions used only one cartridge filled
with cyan, magenta, and yellow ink and one
cartridge filled with black ink. You would have
to throw out the whole cartridge if you ran out
of even one color. Numerous new inkjets come
with separate color cartridges and this is a
consideration if you do any volume printing.
Also many of the newer inkjets can give you good
quality output on laser paper.
Color Laser Printers
Color Laser Printers have a drum that is
charged with static electricity. The drum picks
up colored toner, which sticks to the static.
The drum transfers the toner to the paper. The
toner is then thermally fixed to the paper.
Color laser printers deliver great color, but
they are expensive. You can use plain paper but
a better quality paper will produce better
results. Laser printers produce great looking
and crisp text, but are not noted for the
quality of printed photographs as they are not
continuous tone printers.
Micro-Dry Printers
Micro-Dry
is a computer printing system developed by
the ALPS corporation of Japan. It is a
resin-transfer system using individual
colored thermal ribbon cartridges, and can
print in process color using cyan, magenta,
yellow, and black cartridges, as well as
such spot-color cartridges as white,
metallic silver, and metallic gold, on a
wide variety of paper and transparency
stock. Certain Micro-Dry printers can also
operate in dye sublimation mode, using
special cartridges and paper.
A typical Micro-Dry printer includes a
moving carriage containing the printhead,
which is capable of taking cartridges from a
rack on the front cover of the machine,
printing with them, and returning them to
the rack, without human intervention.
Printing is normally done one color at a
time, printing the entire cyan portion of
the page, then retracting the page to print
the entire magenta portion, then yellow,
then black (or yellow, magenta, cyan, and a
protective overcoat, in dye sublimation
mode). When multiple spot colors are used in
addition to CMYK, the printer can be
manually directed to retract the page at the
end of the printing cycle, instead of
ejecting it, thus assuring that the spot
colors remain in registration.
Because ALPS had little name recognition
among United States consumers, because it
could not interest other major printer
manufacturers in its system, and because it
is considerably slower than most ink-jet
systems, the Micro-Dry system never achieved
wide acceptance, despite its ability to
produce clear, waterproof, fade-resistant
hardcopy. It has found a niche market in
certain types of plotters used in the
signage industry, as well as an extremely
loyal following among those who understand
its capabilities, and ALPS does continue to
produce mechanisms for use in plotters, as
well as supplies, and has pledged to
continue doing so for as long as there is a
significant demand
Micro-Dry printers are much like dye-sub
printers delivering resin-based ink via thermal
transfer from a ribbon. You can use any paper
with a micro-dry printer. There is a slight
banding. It is questionable whether this is from
where the half-inch ribbon swaths stitch
together or from thermal technology, but this
banding is common to many printers that print in
a row, so some banding is natural. The banding
can be avoided by selecting different
backgrounds or subjects. The MD-5000 can produce
vivid and photographic quality prints because it
is a variable dot printer. The Alps patented
printer insures exact control of dot diameter,
resulting in superior print quality. This unique
technology combines a thermal controller chip
and an Alps Micro DOS (Deposit on Silicon) print
head. The controller creates a precision,
high-density print pattern for each dot, selects
the correct ink and fuses the image to the print
surface. The printer is able to size the pixel
into three perfectly shaped dots, accurately
registered. Have you ever designed an image,
picked great colors, and then printed the image
on colored paper and you get totally different
shades of the colors. Well, with the Alps this
doesn't happen. Since the ink stays on the
surface, you can print on colored paper without
the color changing the color of the ink. We
tested the MD-5000 against other laser and
inkjet printers and it produced excellent
results in the micro-dry mode. The text was
clear, the colors were sharp and vivid, even on
just laser paper such as Hammermill. The inks
cost under $10 per color and seem to last.
Dye Sublimation Printers
Dye-sub printers work by transferring colored
dyes by heat (for this reason, you might also
have seen these printers referred to as thermal
dye sublimation printers) The dyes are held on a
ribbon or roll and transferred to the paper when
heated. When the dye hits the paper, it
sublimates, or sinks into the paper--it does not
sit on the paper surface. You cannot use plain
paper in this process; you must use paper that
is made especially for this process. When you
use the proper paper, the dye spreads out a bit
on the paper's glossy surface and mixes with the
other colors, producing a continuous tone much
like that found in a traditional color print.
The prints from the MD-5000 using this mode were
outstanding. You get an extremely professional
look from just a desktop printer. Until now, a
full-page dye sublimation printer has been to
expensive for most people. The cheaper models
printed only smaller pages.
|